Skip to main content

PaycheckZip.com vs Should I Grade It?

A side-by-side comparison built from both listings. Blank cells mean the company has not given that detail; we never guess.

PaycheckZip.com compared with Should I Grade It?
DetailPaycheckZip.com logo PaycheckZip.comShould I Grade It? logo Should I Grade It?
What it does2026 paycheck estimates with line-by-line tax breakdowns for every state Free Pokémon card grade checker
StageNot given Not given
FoundedNot given Not given
Based inNot given Not given
Pricing modelFree Freemium
PricingNot given Free: 7 full scans per month, live scan, grade estimate, values, decision, calculators and collection unlimited. Pro monthly: $3.99/month (rises to $4.99 for new subscribers January 1, 2027), unlimited scans. Pro yearly: $31.99/year, $2.67 per month, save 33% (rises to $39.99 for new subscribers Jan
Key features
  • Salary and hourly paycheck calculator for all 50 states plus DC
  • Line-by-line tax breakdown with sources cited from IRS and state tables
  • W-4 step-by-step configuration with credits and allowances
  • Overtime, tips, bonuses, and pre-tax deduction inputs
  • Local tax calculations for NYC, Yonkers, and Philadelphia
  • Pay stub verification and comparison tools
  • Comparison of job offers after tax
  • Take-home pay map by state
  • Guides on tax topics and paycheck literacy
  • 43 published test cases verifying calculator accuracy
  • PSA grade estimation with centering, corners, edges and surface subgrades measured from photos
  • Card identification using CardSight AI matched to exact TCGplayer printing
  • Raw prices from TCGplayer refreshed daily for each printing variant
  • Graded values from median of recent eBay completed sales for PSA, CGC and Beckett
  • Collection tracker with daily valuation and price history charts synced across devices
  • Grade-or-not verdict calculated after subtracting grading fees, shipping and eBay fees
  • Price guide searchable by card name or number with separate prices for Shadowless, 1st Edition and other printings
  • Grade range showing likely grade plus how far it could swing based on photo limitations
  • Free account with email sign-up, no password required, optional collection sync across devices
What makes it different
  • Cites specific IRS and state tax tables for every line, verified October 9, 2026
  • Line-by-line breakdown shows exactly how each tax is calculated
  • Handles complex scenarios including two jobs, W-4 Step 2, multiple employers, and local taxes
  • Results can be shared without exposing personal data in the URL
  • Clear guidance on limitations: estimates, not tax or payroll advice
  • No download required, runs directly in web browser on phone and computer
  • Built by an actual collector and reseller with dated real-world sales data
  • Independent and unaffiliated with PSA, graders, retailers or Pokémon Company
  • Live camera scanning with auto-straightening works at any angle, including full tilted surface check
  • Compares estimated grade and grading cost against raw and graded comps to show actual profit potential
Community votes00
DR (Domain Rating by Ahrefs)Not checked yet −2 (down) since last checkNot checked yet no change since last check
Trust Flow (Majestic)00
Citation Flow (Majestic)015
Referring domains (Majestic)02

4 details filled in for both companies.

More alternatives to PaycheckZip.com More alternatives to Should I Grade It?

Help centre